In this two-part editorial series, FNS foreign affairs reporter Flynn Dupond questions the Federation’s alliance with an empire built on conquest, subjugation, and conflict.
I recently found myself wandering the main promenade of Starbase 118 along with my daughter. It is usually a bustling hive of ordered chaos, but with the (then) upcoming Khitomer Accords anniversary approaching, everyone was moving about—buying gifts, hanging decorations, etc.
My daughter, a precocious youngster of five, was aware that something special was impending, and asked me what was going on. I attempted to explain that, many years ago, the Federation began to work with the Klingon Empire toward peace. I managed to give a cursory overview without delving into the rich and convoluted history the Empire and the Federation had shared together. Remember, this is a five-year-old I’m trying to communicate with. Even with this ultra-condensed version, my daughter looked thoroughly bored by my ramblings, and with an, “Oh,” she darted off to join her friends and munch on jumja sticks.
As I continued to window shop and keep an eye on her, my eyes were drawn upwards, toward the ceiling, where a Federation banner and a Klingon Empire banner hung side by side. I’d seen such imagery before, and it had often stirred the patriotic portions of my heart for days after. But as I observed that harsh, emblazoned trefoil, my thoughts returned to the abridged lecture I’d just given. In that moment, the alliance between the two previously feuding governments seemed so improbable, so impractical, that I simply couldn’t believe it had held.
Later that night, I began to study the Klingon Empire in detail. I poured over any confirmed and unclassified information I could dredge up, and my findings shocked me. I decided my next piece for the FNS would not be on the Khitomer celebrations. Virtually all of my esteemed colleagues would be following that particular story. Instead, I would delve deeper into one the of the best-kept secrets of the Federation: its abusive, abrasive comrade, the Klingon Empire.
To join the Federation as a member world, a planet must demonstrate several things. The planet must be united under a single governing body. This government may not practice any sort of discrimination, or function with a caste system, and each member of the society must be treated equally and with respect, as outlined in the Rights of Sentience. The planet must also possess some sort of warp technology, however rudimentary. Only after these conditions have been met will the Federation Council begin to consider an application for membership.
Now, it should come as no surprise that the Klingon Empire does not satisfy most of these requirements. Short of having warp technology, this most controversial ally of the Federation is sorely deficient in most of these areas. It should also be noted that the Empire has never expressed an interest in joining the Federation as a member world. However, the question of why the Federation chooses to call this “government” an ally escapes this author’s comprehension, a perspective I hope you will soon understand.
From the first contact between humanity and the Empire, the stereotype that Klingons are brutal, warlike and barbarous has been well-earned. Whereas the United Federation of Planets accepts and absorbs planets and governments only when such attention is sought, the Empire expands its territory under a policy of rampant expansionism. Conquered planets are then subject to the stern laws of the Empire. Resources are strip mined, people are herded into workforces, and the world is turned into what is most valuable to the Empire, instead of utilizing the unique properties of a planet, and allowing that planet to remain undamaged.
History recounts the incident at Organia more than a century ago. As the Federation and the Empire prepared to wage war, a landing force was placed on the planet Organia, in an attempt to secure the particularly strategic position. While the incidents that occurred on the surface of Organia eventually lead to the Organian Peace Treaty that kept the Federation and Klingon Empires from launching an interstellar war, the Klingon leadership attempted to kill two hundred peaceful, innocent inhabitants, in order to expose two Starfleet officers.
This blatant disregard for life is consistent with the general policies of the Empire, even at present. During the brief but disastrously costly Federation-Klingon War of 2372, the Empire annexed several Federation worlds, including Archanis. When the Khitomer Accords were resigned just over a year later, Starfleet and humanitarian personnel arrived to find the utter devastation wrought upon both the planet itself and its inhabitants. One need only look upon the memorials left on these worlds to understand the depth of the damage done by the Klingon Empire—to a former ally, no less.
Stay tuned for part 2 of Flynn Dupond’s examination of the Klingon Empire.
- Bajoran workers down tools in protest over Tejar case - 239511.27
- Reconstruction within Cardassian Union surges ahead of expected timetable - 239510.08
- Trill Symbiosis Commission to update host selection process - 239411.17
- High-profile trial of Cardassian war criminal begins - 239405.17
- Protests erupt over controversial war criminal case - 239402.05
- The Trouble with the Klingon Empire, Part 2 - 239312.30
- The Klingon Empire: Accepted Ally or Tolerated Blot? - 239312.19
- Federation Council refuses Bajoran appeal to host trial of Cardassian war criminal - 239310.06
- Capture of Cardassian war criminal raises questions, tensions - 239306.02
- New Dominion War memoir makes bold accusations against Federation and Starfleet leadership - 239302.15